Update July 9, 2016 – $58 Million Won in San Diego Lawsuit
This could be a game changer. We don’t have many details yet, but here is a short summary:
Jury Awards $58,389,000 to 10 Households of the Terrace View Mobile Home Park in San Diego
SAN DIEGO, July 6, 2016 /PRNewswire/ —
Miguel Aranda, et al. v. Terrace View Partners, L.P.
San Diego Superior Court Case No. 37-2013-00057526
Today, a San Diego civil jury awarded 10 households of the Terrace View Mobile Home Park $58,389,000 in compensatory and punitive damages against the Park owners, Tom Tatum & Jeff Kaplan. The case involved charging unreasonable rents and other illegal practices causing residents to lose their homes.
At the time of trial, 100 of the 200 spaces at the Terrace View Mobile Home Park were empty or abandoned due to the park owners’ practices.
This is the first phase of 49 homes that are part of the lawsuit.
The case was tried by James Allen and Jessica Taylor of San Diego based firm Allen, Semelsberger & Kaelin
Note: This means if you live in a park where the park owner is charging unreasonable rents and using other illegal practices that cause residents to lose their homes, you may have the basis for another lawsuit – with damages in the millions of dollars. Please contact Frank Wodley, publisher, Mobilehome Magazine & President of COMO-CAL: email@example.com / 818-886-6479 to get started.
Update July 1, 2016
Please support MH Life Magazine. Simply go to our GoFundMe account at: gofundme.com/2cc29pmk. We are asking the mobile/manufactured-home community to support our efforts to provide important, useful, honest information via the magazine – at essentially no cost. This is now our 5th year and we can continue only with your assistance. A financial statement of all donations will be provided both via MH Life Magazine and also this website: www.mobilehomemagazine.org
All donations will be used to publish, print and distribute MH Life Magazine. Please help us help you! We thank you for your help.
April 6, 2016 – New Survey
We just mailed out our new Survey on Transparency and Enforcement. Please go to: https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/8DQNY9H. We value your opinion and appreciate your time
March 15, 2016 – Breakthrough
We are very excited to announce that John Bertaut, ex-GSMOL VP and his group (Sacramento Area Coalition of Mobilehome Owners) have accepted our offer of a FREE magazine to help them with their advocacy. They will give the magazine a new name and use it to publish information for residents in the 15 or so parks in their Coalition. We see this as a beginning of our Regional Group Plan, and UNITY (groups will act independently, but share and network via the magazine). John’s Sacramento magazine, as well as others once they come on board, will be displayed on a new website, perhaps titled United Mobilehome Owners of California.
Now your advocacy can have a voice via the magazine. We will offer the magazine FREE to any advocacy in California who serves mobilehome owners. All we ask is for you to be transparent and responsive to those you serve. Call Frank for details (818-886-6479). We especially would like to see our friends in San Jose and Hemet get on board. Lets work together.
March 5, 2016 Formation Meeting Regional Groups
COMO-CAL held their first meeting to address forming Regional Groups around the state of California. We’ve been writing about reorganizing advocacy groups since November 2014, and now it is actually happening. We met at Frank Wodley’s park – Chatsworth Mobilehome Park, in Chatsworth (L.A. San Fernando Valley). Attending were representatives from San Marcos (Lloyd Rochambeau, President of SMMRA (San Marcos)), Carol Spizzirri Vice President of SMMRA, Floyd Folden (Oxnard), Paul Masminster (Save Our Souls – Torrance), Jerilyn Schimandle (Sylmar), Frank Wodley (President of COMO-CAL) and Ken and Sam Meng (MRA 1441 – Rowland Heights).
Photo Left to Right: Lloyd Rochambeau, Sam Meng, Jerilyn Shimandle, Frank Wodley, Ken Meng, Paul Masminster, Carol Spizzirri, Robert Florian
UPDATE ON GSMOL
The meeting began with an update on the crisis brought about by the demise of GSMOL and the loss of the lobbyist,Brian Augusta, who represented MH owners interests in Sacramento. Our efforts, to warn the Community that this was inevitable unless action was taken to remove the “bad apple board members” leading GSMOL, fell on deft ears. Had the Community acted on our alerts, and had GSMOL leaders embraced our suggestions and assistance, GSMOL would still be viable today. Now it is too late. Two Vice Presidents have resigned because they encountered a majority board much like that described in George Smith’s Lawsuit in 1999. Their resignations validate what we have been saying all along – GSMOL is being run by a small group more interested in themselves than MH owners. They have conspired to deceive MH owners into thinking GSMOL is “alive and well,” and that they have been doing a terrific job, when in fact GSMOL has been losing members and income since the late 1980’s. Today it is out of money and won’t survive. The latest Californian is another example of their deception. There is NO MENTION of any crisis in GSMOL. It is “business as usual.” When in fact it is very far from “business as usual.” Those leaving predict GSMOL can continue only a few more months.
Contrary to misconceptions by some, there have been times when COMO-CAL and GSMOL worked very well together. GSMOL’s focus has always been Sacramento (after all that’s why they are a 501(c)4 – a nonprofit that can lobby). COMO-CAL’s focus has always been grass roots, working with HOA’s and residents on issues they face in their parks (COMO-CAL is a 501(c)3 – we are a nonprofit that can not lobby). The loss of a lobbyist, representing our interests in Sacramento, should be a huge RED FLAG to all MH owners in California. The Community simply can not afford to turn a blind eye anymore. This can soon have HUGE CONSEQUENCES if we do not UNITE and work together.
The Regional Group Plan Works
The balance of the meeting focused on The Regional Group Plan. The RG Plan works. It gets advocates working together for the first time in many years. It eliminates competition. Regional leaders now have the resources to really make a difference in their area. No one is telling them how to advocate. No one is taking money from their members. Each Regional Group (RG) works independently of the rest of the state. Each RG communicates, networks, and shares with all other RG’s. NO ONE IS AN ISLAND.
Nuts and Bolts
- The Magazine will continue to be the life blood of the RG Plan. Each RG would have its own Magazine. Regional leaders will rename it to suit their area and focus.
- Each RG would decide how they would advocate: a) whether or not to have members, b) what issues to deal with first, c) a resolution process, etc.
- Monies collected will be used by the local RG. If and when there are enough resources to hire a lobbyist and/or attorney, all RGs will contribute their share.
- We suggest all RG leaders take the Pledge to be transparent and open (financial statements), responsive to members, and agree to network, share and communicate with all other advocates.
We see no problem starting a Regional Group for L.A., Orange County and North County San Diego by June 2016. And we hope our efforts here in Southern California will be embraced by advocate leaders in Northern California. We can no longer afford to be divided. Strength in Numbers. Our hope is all MH owners get behind our efforts to UNITE.
We have taken Updates off the HOME page. You can now find important updates on the menu above. Much is happening to advocacy today and you should be informed by visiting UPDATES on a regular basis.
Resident Association Endorses COMO-CAL
I am the founder and president of the 1441 Manufactured-Home Residents Association (MRA1441), which was formed to serve residents and improve our community. Our family moved into Rowland Heights Mobile Estates in July, 2012, after our home was foreclosed in 2011. By the time we moved in, we found residents were being discriminated against and oppressed by park management, and many of the elderly were complaining that living at Rowland Heights ME was like living in a jail. Photo: Ken Meng (right) with Frank Wodley at Frank’s home in Chatsworth.
In early 2013, MRA1441 was created. In May, we organized a protest, and at the end of the year, after much research and hard work, organized a meeting with the park owner. We represented over 175 residents. As a result, the park owner finally decided to replace their abusive management, did not raise the rent on residents for one year, fixed the roads, extended clubhouse hours, and made other improvements. By organizing residents, we overcame retaliation and profoundly learned that when vulnerable residents unite, they become powerful and are then able to protect their rights.
Residents in one park can only do so much, so we began reaching out to other mobilehome organizations. Although we did not receive effective help from GSMOL, we did connect with COMO-CAL after reading a copy of MH Life Magazine. We appreciated the Magazine for courageously standing up for residents, and pointing out problems in California mobilehome parks. Through much contact with Frank Wodley, we found him to be honest, enthusiastic, hard working, he disregards personal gains, and is a person who strives to do his best. At one time he was a manger with GSMOL, however he was concerned about the lack of enforcement and the direction of the organization. Therefore in 2004 he decided to form COMO-CAL and MH Life Magazine. The Magazine is the only publication telling the truth about advocacy and issues found in mobilehome parks. We clearly recognize that Frank Wodley’s efforts and selfless dedication are due only because of his desire to help a vulnerable group of residents receive just treatment.
COMO-CAL’s Regional Plan effectively helps residents, but only if residents support it. Individual park associations are the foundation of the Regional Plan. This organization motivates residents to stand up, through unity, to resolve specific problems found in their community. The Regional Plan also provides important resources: a legal fund to provide legal assistance and a Magazine to educate and inform. The “organization” fundamentally differs from that of GSMOL. If residents embrace this plan, we predict residents will have a tremendously effective tool for dealing with park owners and park managers.
As with MRA, COMO-CAL encourages residents of mobilehome parks to establish their own community resident organizations instead of only depending on protection by another organization or government agency. Similar to unions, it is the only way to protect a vulnerable group like the mobile home residents in California. By putting local residents in positions of power and providing transparency to the group, only people with a true desire to help their fellow mobilehome residents will join in the leadership of COMO-CAL as it provides no other incentive.
After reading this endorsement, I encourage you to organize at least a few residents in your park and join COMO-CAL. Even if it is only you for now, COMO-CAL can help inform and educate you and help you organize. You can adopt a name like Manufactured-Home Residents Association for your new group, i.e. a group that promotes the general welfare of residents in your park. And you can make it specific to your park by adopting your parks address, as the Rowland Heights group did (1441).
MRA1441 endorses COMO-CAL. California residents should organize and unite through COMO-CAL for the welfare of their future generations and the future of mobilehome residents. Even if you are a GSMOL member or officer, we suggest you embrace the Regional Plan if your true desire is to serve and help residents. The Plan means resources stay in regions where they will do the most good, and gets everyone working together, effectively and efficiently. It provides for Strength in Numbers!
–Ken Meng, President, 1441 Manufactured-Home Residents Association (MRA1441), Rowland Heights, CA. firstname.lastname@example.org. (626) 581-6580
Editor’s Note: I’m thrilled to be working with Ken Meng and MRA1441. Through much adversity (these folks are mainly Chinese speaking and are not fluent in English), they have accomplished so much. If you have a computer I suggest you visit their website (http://mra1441.org/). Photo: Members of MRA1441.
Photos can be accessed at https://www.flickr.com/photos/110013505@N07/. Each has is a wealth of information including letters from the park attorney and the unlawful detainer action.
Next month we will publish more of their story, their demonstrations, confrontations with management, the lawsuit to evict Ken Meng, and how his 17 year old son Sam was instrumental in helping them win the lawsuit. Their determination and perseverance are to be commended. Congratulations Ken Meng, his family, and their residents association MRA1441!